Table 1 Characteristics and results of individual sources of evidence. Scoping review on maternal and congenital syphilis in Indigenous Peoples, 2021.
From: Maternal and congenital syphilis in Indigenous Peoples: a scoping review of the worldwide literature
[Ref. number] First Author (publication year) | Data collection year1 | Continent2; country; region | Public. language3 | Public. type4 | Std dsgn5 | Population; Ethnic determination6; participants7 | Topics covered8 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
DQ | DAH | DF | DT | OCS | |||||||
[11] Cândido (2012) | 2007–2010 | SA; Brazil; Mato Grosso do Sul state | Pt | MD | E | Several; SD; 344 cases in pw | X | X | |||
[12] Tiago (2017) | 2011–2014 | SA; Brazil; Mato Grosso do Sul state | Pt | SP | E | Several; VR; 316 ms, 69 cs | X | X | |||
[13] Nonato (2020) | 2013–2017 | SA; Brazil; Rio Branco, Acre state | Pt | SP | DCS | Several; SD; 15 pw | X | ||||
[14] Palma-Pinedo (2012) | 2014 | SA; Peru; Amazonia | Spn | SP | QLQ | Health workers; NA; 122 health unites and respective health workers | X | ||||
[15] McLeod (2015) | 2009–2014 | OC; Australia; Northern Territory | En | SP | VR | Several; NI; 31pw | X | ||||
[16] Benzaken (2011) | 2009–2011 | SA; Brazil; Amazonia | En | CA | CS | Several; VR; 3650 pw | X | ||||
[17] Carvalho (2011) | 2009–2011 | SA; Brazil; Amazonia | En | CA | CE | Several; VR; NI | X | ||||
[18] Domingues (2014) | 2011–2012 | SA; Brazil; National | En | SP | CS | Several; SD; 99 pw | X | X | |||
[19] Garnelo (2019) | 2008–2009 | SA; Brazil; National | Pt | SP | CS | Several; SD; 3.967 pw | X | ||||
[20] Picoli (2020) | 2018 | SA; Brazil; Mato Grosso do Sul state | Pt | SP | QLQ | Health workers; NA; 33 nurses from the indigenous health system | X | ||||
[21] Schmeing (2012) | 2012 | SA; Brazil; Amambai, Mato Grosso do Sul state | Pt | MD | QLQ | Health workers; NA; 24 health workers | X | ||||
[22] Ruffinen (2015) | 2008 | SA; Brazil; Amazônia, Alto Solimões | En | SP | QLQ | Ticuna; MPC; 6473 indigenous (pw not informed) | X | X | |||
[23] Da Costa Ribeiro (2014) | 2009–2011 | SA; Brazil; Amazônia | En | CA | CS | Several; NI; 967w (81,1% indigenous) | X | X | |||
[24] CDC (2010) | 2007–2009 | NA; EUA; Arizona | En | RP | D | Southwest Indian Nation; MPC; 106 cases (6 cs) | X | X | |||
[25] Bowen (2018) | 2013–2015 | NA; EUA; NI | En | SP | D | American Indian/Alaska Native; VR; 136 cases (2 cs) | X | X | |||
[26] Miele (2020) | 2014–2018 | NA; EUA; National | En | CA | E | American Indian/ Alaska Native; NI; 35 cs | X | X | X | ||
[27] Bornay-Llinares (2014) | 2012–2013 | SA; Argentina; Missiones | En | CA | CS | Guarani-Mbya; VR; 652 (342w, 250 < 10yo) | X | X | |||
[28] Marx (2020) | NI | SA; Argentina; Puerto Iguazú | En | SP | CS | Mbyá-Guarani; VR; 551 (90 children) | X | X | |||
[29] Bright (2016) | 2011–2015 | OC; Australia; Queensland, North. Territ. & Western Australia | En | SP | D | Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders; VR; 790 cases (7 cs) | X | X | |||
[30] How (1994) | 1989–1991 | OC; Australia; North West Mildura | En | SP | CS | Aboriginal; MPC; 71pw | X | X | X | X | |
[31] Benzaken (2017) | 2009–2011 | SA; Brazil; Amazonia | En | SP | CS | Several; VR; 3650 pw | X | X | |||
[32] Panaretto (2006) | 2000–2003 | OC; Australia; Townsville | En | SP | CS; CH | Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander; SD; 432 pw | X | X | X | ||
[33] Ormaeche (2012) | 2007–2008 | SA; Peru; Amazonia | En | SP | CS | Several; VR; 1251 pw, 697 partners | X | X | |||
[34] Burton (2019) | 2011–2014 | OC; Australia; Northern Territory | En | SP | CC | Northern Territory Indigenous births; SD or BR; 380 cases (preterm birth) and 380 controls | X | ||||