Skip to main content

Table 2 Summary of included articles

From: Saying and doing are different things: a scoping review on how health equity is conceptualized when considering healthcare system performance

Authors

Year of publication

Country of origin/under study

Study Design

Overview of Data Analysis Tools Used

Indicators Provided

Anderson et al [15]

2018

U.S

Quantitative

n/a -equity roadmap proposal

n/a

Asaria et al [9]

2016

UK

Quantitative

Lower super output area

Index of multiple deprivation

Slope index of inequity (SII)

Relative index of inequality (RII)

Primary care supply

Primary care quality

Preventable hospitalization

Amenable mortality

Buja et al [11]

2015

Italy

Quantitative

unconditional exploratory logistic regression analysis of indicators

Indicators of processes:

1. patients with STEMI-AMI not treated with percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI)

2. older patients with hip fractures undergoing surgery more than 48 h after being admitted to hospital

3. open cholecystectomies

4. women undergoing caesarean section

Burström et al [12]

2017

Sweden

Scoping Review- Mixed Methods

Donabedian's framework for assessing quality of care

n/a

Cohen et al [13]

2018

Ontario

Qualitative

NVivo qualitative data analysis software

Content analysis

15 indicators, placed into five categories:

1. Assess/report inequities

2. Modify/orient programs/services

3. Engage in community and multi sectoral collaboration in addressing the health needs of populations through services and programs

4. Lead/support/participate with others to address policies

5. Organizational and development role

Cookson et al [10]

2018

England

Quantitative

Lower super output area

Index of multiple deprivation

Linear regression

Absolute gradient index

Quality of ambulatory care services in managing long term conditions

Freeman et al [16]

2018

Australia

Mixed Methods

QSR NVivo software for thematic analysis

n/a

Lavoie et al [17]

2018

Canada

Mixed Methods

Socio-historical narrative of each clinic

Analysis of board meeting minutes and funding contracts for each clinic

n/a

Li et al [18]

2018

China

Quantitative

4-level hierarchical random effects models

4-level regression model

n/a

Lloren et al [19]

2019

United States

Quantitative

hospital‐specific random coefficient for patient dual eligibility status or African American race

Sensitivity analyses

n/a

Saia et al [20]

2018

Italy

Quantitative

predictive models

multilevel logistic regression

The proportion of patients with heart attacks treated with primary percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) within 24 h

The proportion of in-hospital deaths among patients treated for hearth attacks

Sebastián et al [14]

2017

Sweden

Quantitative

The horizontal inequity index (HII)

probit regression

the concentration index

Socioeconomic indicator individual disposable income

Shah et al [21]

2015

United States

Quantitative

multivariable analysis

descriptive statistics

logistic regression models

n/a

Smithman et al [22]

2018

Canada

Quantitative

Social and material area deprivation indexes

multiple logistic regression

Pearson chi-squared test

n/a

Vallières et al [23]

2016

Sierra Leone

Quantitative

Pearson Chi-Squared test

Maternal health

child health

sanitation

Ward et al [24]

2020

India

Quantitative

survey-weighted logistic regression

survey logistic regression

wealth index

Benjamini–Hochberg correction

Indicator categories:

Reproductive

Maternal

Newborn

Child health

Nutrition

NOTE: Indicators were relevant to interventions across the continuum of care and health disparities. For each continuum of care domain, researchers also classified the indicators by delivery platform