Skip to main content

Table 4 Example of a separate summary of findings table because of expected differences for disadvantaged population

From: Extending the PRISMA statement to equity-focused systematic reviews (PRISMA-E 2012): explanation and elaboration

 

Positive

Neutral

Negative

Mixed

Unclear

Total

Increases in price/tax of tobacco products

14

6

4

1

2

27

Smokefree-voluntary, regional, partial

1

1

19

0

4

25

Smokefree-compulsory, national, comprehensive

2

9

6

1

4

19

Mass media campaigns

3

2

5

2

6

18

Mass media campaigns-quitlines and NRT

5

3

3

0

1

12

Controls on advertising, promotion and marketing of tobacco

2

7

0

0

 

9

Population-level cessation support interventions

4

2

0

1

2

9

Setting based interventions(community, workplace, hospital)

2

4

1

0

0

7

Multiple policies

0

2

0

1

1

4

Total policies

33

36

38

6

17

130a

Total studies

31b

30

37

6

14b

117

  1. Summary equity impact of included studies and policies
  2. aEight studies assessed more than one type of pilocy Dinno 200935 = Smokefree, Price/Tax; Frieden 200549 = Smoke, Price/Tax, Multiple policies; Hawk 99 = Mass Media, Mass Media-quitlines and NRT; Hawkins 2012 53 = Smokefree, Price/Tax
  3. bLevy 200641 = Smokefree, Price/Tax, Mass Media; Nagelhout 201354 = Smokefree, Price/Tax Media; Scaap 200847 = Smokefree, Price/Tax, Controls on advertising, promotion and marketing of tobacco, Multiple policies; Wilson 2010a115 = Controls on advertising, promotion and marketing of tobacco, Mass media-quitlines and NRT
  4. [95]