Skip to main content

Table 3 Inequalities in patient-provider interaction and treatment received

From: Quality of care for the treatment for uncomplicated malaria in South-East Nigeria: how important is socioeconomic status?

 

Poorest 40%

Third 20%

Fourth 20%

Richest 20%

All

P-value

n (%) [95% CI]*

n (%) [95% CI]*

n (%) [95% CI]*

n (%) [95% CI]*

n (%) [95% CI]*

 

N = 362

N = 292

N = 423

N = 565

N = 1642

 

Nature of interaction

Told HW about fever(a)

312 (75.2) [61.0-85.5]

220 (54.7) [42.1-66.6]

248 (44.1) [36.3-52.2]

255 (36.1) [25.9-47.7]

1035 (44.3) [37.3-51.4]

<0.001

HW asked questions about illness(b)

252 (59.9) [47.8-70.9]

184 (41.7) [27.9-56.9]

211 (36.2) [28.6-44.6]

228 (29.7) [20.2-41.3]

875 (35.7) [29.1-43.1]

0.011

Patient was physically examined

116 (21.9) [13.6-33.2]

101 (14.8) [9.2-22.9]

85 (7.6) [4.4-13.1]

101 (9.8) [5.7-16.2]

403 (10.8) [7.9-14.5]

0.031

Patient had temperature taken

98 (16.8) [9.7-27.5]

69 (7.6) [4.6-12.2]

49 (3.4) [2.0-5.7]

54 (4.4) [1.9-9.8]

270 (5.5) [3.9-7.8]

0.007

Patient was tested for malaria

7 (1.0) [0.6-1.7]

6 (1.0) [0.7-1.4]

3 (0.2) [0.1-0.6]

11 (0.8) [0.3-2.3]

27 (0.7) [0.3-1.3]

0.076

Requested a specific medicine

54 (23.3) [13.4-37.4]

85 (49.0) [36.8-61.4]

215 (63.6) [54.7-71.7]

328 (68.1) [57.2-77.4]

682 (60.5) [53.7-66.9]

<0.001

For those that requested specific medicine, type of treatment requested N = 676

Antimalarial(c)

27 (69.5) [40.2-88.5)

69 (81.3) [56.6-93.5)

195 (93.7) [86.4-97.2]

295 (89.1) [82.1-93.5)

586 (89.1) [83.1-93.1]

0.057

ACT(c)

6 (26.2) [5.9-66.6]

12 [13.8) [5.6-30.1]

46 (24) [14.7-36.7)

85 (27.0) [18.6-37.5]

149 (24.5) [17.7-32.9]

0.458

Artesunate monotherapy(c)

2 (3.9) [0.5-23.9]

11 (13.8) [5.6-30.4)

39 (18.7) [12.3-27.3]

61 (18.5) [13.4-25.1]

113 (17.6) 13.6-22.4)

0.452

Sulphadoxine Pyrimethamine(c)

13 (32.1) [11.7-62.8]

35 (41.8) [25.0-60.7]

89 (43.4) [33.9-53.4]

126 (37.9) [28.3-48.5]

263 (39.9) [33.0-47.3]

0.741

Other type of antimalarial(c)

6 (7.3) [2.1-22.1]

11 (11.9) [4.8-26.6]

21 (7.7) [3.8-15.0]

23 (5.7) [3.3-9.5]

61 (7.1) [4.9-10.2]

0.395

Antibiotic(c)

7 (7.8) [2.7-20.6]

5 (8.7) [2.0-30.9]

8 (5.0) [1.9-12.1]

21 (6.1) [3.0-12.0]

41 (6.1) [3.5-10.4]

0.775

Antipyretic(c)

19 (31.7) [16.1-52.8]

38 (46.3) [30.4-62.9]

101 (45.9) [35.8-56.4]

162 (50.0) [40.8-59.2]

320 (47.7) [41.1-54.5]

0.563

For those that requested specific medicine, treatment received N = 586

Antimalarial

22 (93.8) [80.8-98.2]

64 (96.5) [86.1-99.2]

190 (98.0) [92.5-99.5]

274 (93.4) [82.0-97.8]

550 (95.3) [89.8-97.9]

0.265

ACT

5 (96.7) [74.5-99.7]

9 (74.4) [22.5-96.7]

43 (95.7) [79.0-99.2]

68 (83.7) [54.3-95.7]

125 (87.3) [67.6-95.8]

0.235

Artesunate monotherapy

1(77.9) [12.6-98.9]

10 (87.8) [27.4-99.3]

37 (94.2) [67.4-99.2]

49 (85.0) [57.2-91.3]

97 (85.0) [68.8-93.6]

0.316

Sulphadoxine Pyrimethamine

11 (94.4) [71.9-99.1]

32 (97.2) [86.3-99.5]

86 (96.3) [83.0-99.3]

120 (96.2) [86.8-99.0]

249 (96.3) [91.4-98.5]

0.948

Other type of antimalarial(c)

3 (66.1 [23.5-92.5]

9 (81.2) [29.4-97.8)

15 (64.7) [30.8-88.3]

17 (75.6) [54.9-85.2]

44 (72.5) [54.9-85.2]

0.789

Antibiotic(c)

5 (70.7) [30.7-92.9]

5 (100)

7 (90.3) [41.5-99.2]

19 (89.2) [42.5-98.9]

36 (90.6) [64.7-98.1]

0.704

Antipyretic(c)

17 (93.2) [70.3-98.8]

36 (89.9) [65.9-97.6]

97 (94.4) [81.1-98.5]

154 (96.2) [90.6-98.5]

304 (94.9) [88.6-97.8]

0.444

Treatment received for all febrile patients N = 1642

Antimalarial

179 (58.1) [46.01-69.3]

184 (71.9) [60.5-81.1]

339 (87.0) [80.7-91.5]

424 (80.1) [72.1-86.2]

1126 (79.3) [74.5-83.4]

<0.001

ACT

38 (11.3) [4.6-24.9]

58 (18.1) [10.3-29.8]

91 (22.0) [15.1-30.8]

128 (25.7) [19.3-33.4]

315 (22.4) [17.0-28.8]

0.100

Artesunate monotherapy

10 (3.5) [1.3-9.2]

22 (9.9) [4.8-19.1]

44 (13.2) [8.8-19.3]

82 (16.2) [12.1-21.3]

158 (13.4) [10.6-16.7]

0.053

Sulphadoxine Pyrimethamine

84 (30.7) [20.3-43.6]

82 (35.6) [24.8-48.2]

178 (45.8) [36.4-55.5]

192 (34.6) [26.4-43.9]

536 (37.9) [31.9-44.3]

0.117

Other type of antimalarial

47 (12.6) [7.3-20.9]

27 (10.9) [6.1-18.7]

29 (6.8) [3.6-12.4]

42 (7.4) [4.7-11.5]

145 (8.2) [6.1-10.7]

0.327

Antibiotic

76 (16.0) [10.7-23.3]

39 (10.8) [5.6-19.8]

27 (6.8) [3.8-11.7]

51 (8.4) [5.6-12.5]

193 (8.8) [6.8-11.3)

0.138

Antipyretic

226 (59.4) [49.3-68.7]

167 (56.7) [44.1-68.4]

211 (52.3) [42.6-61.8]

270 (50.8) [43.3-58.3]

875 (52.8) [47.7-57.8]

0.584

For those that received ACT

Received ACT in correct dose

25 (56.5) [17.4-88.9]

47 (77.0) [53.2-90.8]

48 (62.4) [42.6-78.7]

81 (67.7) [45.3-84.2]

201 (67.0) [53.3-78.2]

0.716

Patient knows regimen

20 (48.1) [15.2-82.7]

41 (72.4) [47.8-88.2]

41 (54.3) [31.3-75.6]

67 (59.8) [36.4-79.5]

169 (59.5) [43.7-73.5]

0.655

  1. *Population averaged percentages and corresponding 95% confidence intervals, which have been adjusted for the survey design. (a)Missing one response (b)Missing two responses (c)Missing 11 responses.