Levin-Lin-Chu test | Im, Pesaran and Shin test | ADF-Fisher test | Pesaran’s simple test | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Levels | equalization1 | 1.668 | 4.625 | 40.423 | 0.872 |
equalization2 | 3.438 | 5.394 | 23.514 | 2.475 | |
self | −5.815** | −3.216** | 176.639** | 1.238 | |
transfer | 10.398 | 13.971 | 0.976 | −0.946 | |
gdpg | −1.498 | −1.197 | 54.575 | −1.602 | |
education | −4.436** | −2.585** | 4.094 | −6.582** | |
dependency | −2.617** | −1.444 | 78.900 | −2.087* | |
urbanization | −0.949 | 3.306 | 79.842 | −1.582 | |
population | −4.032** | −0.756 | 167.540** | −0.905 | |
Difference | d_equalization1 | −6.984** | −6.54** | 192.482** | −2.908** |
d_equalization2 | −5.027** | −6.804** | 249.782** | −6.042** | |
d_self | −7.563** | −7.729** | 169.105** | −3.514** | |
d_transfer | −4.195** | − 3.157** | 60.952** | − 3.805** | |
d_gdpg | −9.191** | −10.531** | 238.575** | −4.769** | |
d_education | −12.749** | −14.756** | 354.954** | −10.993** | |
d_dependency | −11.878** | −12.309** | 190.559** | −7.640** | |
d_urbanization | −5.895** | −5.769** | 166.369** | −4.812** | |
d_population | −6.956** | −8.986** | 170.687** | −7.907** |