Doctor A | Doctor B | Doctor C | Doctor D | Doctor E |
Challenges in treating immigrants | ||||
Patients often not proactive | Needs more time to talk with/understand | Level of difficulty depends on how long patient was in their previous country | Level of difficulty depends how long they’ve been in Canada | Can be difficult adjusting communication to their level |
Not sure they follow her advice | Not always sure they understand what she said and vice versa | Some are compliant but not proactive | Some immigrants have different perspectives on health. | Different approaches to medicine can be hard: many cultures not preventive |
Hard to explain different concepts | Difficult to approach topic of background: where to start? | |||
Hard to advise on psychosocial aspects but they play big role | Unknown daily parts of life that influence health, but neither side thinks to ask about | |||
Beliefs can conflict | ||||
Expectations | ||||
Unclear what they expect her role to be | Sometimes they don’t follow advice because it’s different in their country | Different expectations of medicine (e.g. cures from pills) | Expects patients to take control of own health. | Sometimes they initially expect same treatment as they get in home country |
Understanding | ||||
Education makes a difference to how much they understand | Patients don’t always understand the health system. | Education makes a difference how much the they understand/respond to treatment. | It takes time for patients to understand the healthcare system. | Don’t always understand: |
- role of the doctor | ||||
- health system | ||||
Keys to success/ideas for improvement | ||||
More accessible community resources for psychosocial aspects | Adjusts approach depending on integration level | Understand bigger picture of where they come from | Both doctors and patients can adapt and meet in the middle | Establish rapport |
Translators, even if person speaks English | Cultural sensitivity training | Interpreters would be useful | Be open to idea they won’t always take advice | |
Questions about culture on health history form | Explain system when they first arrive | |||
Patient A | Patient B | Patient C | Patient D | Patient E |
(Philippines) | (China) | (Trinidad) | (Philippines) | (Brazil) |
Attitudes/background | ||||
Lived in 3 different countries (Saudi Arabia, Malaysia, Canada) | Eats healthy, tries to get physical activity | Took about 10 yearsto adjust to the culture | Medical advice falls in line with her own beliefs | Lives healthy lifestyle |
Follows doctor advice but follows own diet | Believes in needing to adapt to new culture fully and with an open mind | Medical advice falls in line with own beliefs because she reads what’s going on in the country and tries to adapt | Learned to become healthier after pregnancy | Was willing to learn and adapt to Canadian syste |
Dismisses difficult experiences with moving: one has to adapt | Hard to adapt at first | People who complain don’t accept that the system is just different | ||
Healthcare experience in home country | ||||
No healthcare in previous countries, have to pay for everything. | Had to pay for everything, much poorer conditions (e.g. no privacy from other patients) | Not as developed | Nothing free, have to pay for everything | Used to going to hospital for everything |
Has pacemaker, wouldn’t have got that in Trinidad | ||||
Healthcare experience in Canada | ||||
Free care | Advice matches own beliefs. | All her needs are taken care of | Her expectations of the treatment are always met | Likes concept of family doctor and having history |
Learned more about health | ||||
Bad experience before present clinic | Problems finding doctor at first | Previous doctor was not attentive or caring | Problems finding doctor at first | Doesn’t like wait times |
Long wait times, would rather pay and not have to wait. | ||||
Experience with present doctor | ||||
Likes doctor: good pep talks very happy | Likes doctor: supportive answers questions | Loves doctor: takes care of her concerns takes time with her | Likes doctor: makes her laugh feel comfortable truly cares | Likes doctor: takes time explains listens |